Monday, November 26, 2012
Wiki Page
The best way for the Wiki to be formatted is for each country to have its own wiki page. Thus, information can be uploaded to the Wiki about each country. In each page, there can be subcategories that break the country down even further. Each country should have its own wiki page, which would teach learn the most about each country.
How the Wiki Page Should Be Formatted
I think that the best way to approach the wiki page is by splitting it up by country and each country should have the same sections o its easy to compare. For example if we are doing China then the page should have sections labeled articulation, aggregation, policy making, and so on through all of the major comparable parts of government and their functions. At the end of the page there should be a section that describes what is unique to that country and have a summary of the overall form of government and policy making at the beginning. Diagrams and charts would also be helpful. I think the main thing is to use information that will be on the tests and is from the book.
For the Wiki Pages I think it would be most helpful if there were a "homepage" which showed the country's name (obviously), and then a list of tabs: Political Culture and Socialization, Interest Groups (including aggregation and articulation), Political Parties and electoral process(?), history of the nation (where did their traditions come from ect.), and perhaps a Political Structures tab as well. Then, within each of these tabs it could be somewhat like a blog format where someone can post something and people can comment below it from there- this way everything is organized in a general manner, and people can see how things were discussed chronologically.
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Neo-Corporatism
The best interest group system is the Neo-Corporatist
Interest system. Although the Pluralist System allows for more diversity in the interest groups and views, the Pluralist system is lacking in efficiency. Because there
are many conflicting groups in the Pluralist system, policy making is
difficult. And although the Corporatist model is very efficient, it too has a downside.
In the Corporatist model the government has too much power over the interests
being articulated. There is usually a lack representation of all of the views
and opinions. Many time in the Corporatist model the articulation of all of the
different interests are sacrificed in return for efficiency. The
Neo-Corporatist Interest system is a good halfway point between these two
systems. The Neo-Corporatist Interest system balances the need for the
representation of many different views and opinions with the need for efficiency.
This system is the most fair and effective interest group system.
Neo-Corporatism is the way to go
neo-corporatism
i believe is the best kind of interest group system for a nation
because of its connection with policy making. Although there may be only
one group for each area, the answer to problems are resolved and
implemented with precision and speed. With a pluralist interest group
system there are numerous groups for each view on an area of expertise.
This allows for a more diverse, but more decentralized organizational
structure. Because of this policy implementation is harder because of
the separation of government and the interest group. With a controlled
interest system, the views are separated by social sector, creating an
imbalance in interest articulation rendering democracy useless. Without
finding a proper balance between interest articulation and government a
nation cannot be a liberal democracy.
Interest Group Systems
There needs to be a balance between structure and breathing
room. A democratic corporatist group provides that necessary balance. It is
focused on each societal interest, not just one. The big problem with
pluralists is that multiple groups only focus on one part of society and that
is inefficient in bringing out the needs of everyone else. The problem with
controlled interest is that there may be too much structure and it's too
focused. Usually these interest groups are part of an authoritarian government.
There are bound to be these problems. A democratic corporatist group system has
the right amount of structure that is needed, but it doesn't have too much
structure. It has different focuses that strives to provide benefits to
everyone. Unlike pluralists, people get more focused. Pluralists only have one
dimension. Controlled interest groups have too much regulation and there is
such thing as necessary deregulation. Too much regulation leads to unhappiness
of the people. Democratic corporatist groups are in the middle of these and are
beneficial to most people. When looking at all of the interest groups from a
perspective, balance is the key for happiness of the people. People like
balance. These other two interest group systems are completely divided. Both
have positive and negative effects. Democratic corporatists have both positive
effects from these other interest groups and are most beneficial to these
people because of the balance it provides. Balance leads to more positive
effects to not only the people, but also the government and its system,
structure, and function.
What's the best?
All three interest group systems have the potential to be successful in their own ways, but the one that I think to be most likely is a democratic neo-corporatist system. A pluralist system is good in that it gives every person a voice without fear of government control. However, there are almost too many voices to all be heard or to even be taken seriously. A pluralist system will result in a lot of protests and demonstrations that have no result and there won’t be any progress in this system. A controlled system is good in that there will be progress because the interest groups actually work directly with the government and the government will listen to them. But the downside is that they are by and by controlled by the government so the voices are not entirely what the people might actually be thinking or wanting to say. The reason I believe a democratic neo-corporatist system to be the best is that it’s the middle ground between the two. It will have more progress than the pluralist system, but the people will have more say than in a controlled system. Additionally, having a single peak association in charge will create a sense of order and organization in the system which will increase the legitimacy of the system. Pluralist and controlled systems are extremes in opposite directions, and the democratic neo-corporatist system is a form of compromise in the middle of the two.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)